There appears to be no way just to download the PDFs. That would be most useful for an eInk device (battery lasts ages, cheap and easy to recharge with solar or a hand-crank).
They don't seem to list the information anywhere, either.
No mobile version is an oversight. It's easier to power a phone in an emergency than it is to power a laptop or desktop.
- Since this is python, it could be served via a Raspberry Pi or similar low power device, then you connect via mobile over wifi. This allows multiple people to use it at once.
- There is an iPad build on github. Presumably the authors don't want to pay the fee to build official iPad apps (which is surprisingly expensive).
I'm not sure about the PDFs, it seems logical/easy to do, but it might end up being too large to store, and might be something you'd generate manually for certain topics.
If it's important to share, every modern phone can act as a hotspot / server. That would be a lot easier than something which has to run from a dedicated computer.
This looks like one of those projects where the intention is good, but no one has sat down and talked to potential users or disaster recovery experts.
There's a mobile section on github that can compile and deploy to an iPad. So they are clearly working on an iOS version. It just has limitations that need to be overcome.
Also, iPhones can sort of serve HTTP, so long as the app doing the serving is in the foreground the entire time. My experience is Apple does not have serving HTTP as an approved method for running in background mode, that's limited to stuff like audio playback and such. This is probably why the mobile version of Lastbook doesn't support networking, and is just a native Swift application.
"fee to build official iPad apps (which is surprisingly expensive)"
The monetary cost is only the beginning. The approval process is onerous and slow, and getting worse with the onslaught of AI slop clogging up the queue.
But, also, locked-down devices, like iOS or now Android, are not what I want to rely on if the shit hits the fan.
> Since this is python, it could be served via a Raspberry Pi or similar low power device
Booking is assuming the end of civilization, probably chaos, migration.. i can imagine, that if you can power one device, would make much more sense a small e-ink tablet, not python served via raspi AND a device to read it..
Okay. In end of the world situations - this sucks I suppose. But we don't need everyone to have "rebuilding civilization" knowledge. Just one person nearby with a Macbook running this will be enough. So if you want to be out with your e-ink tablet, I suppose you'll want to make friends.
But the ultimate in resiliency is to learn all this stuff now. I can already do first aid, can/preserve food, have water purification on hand, wire up a solar setup, make basic repairs to anything in my home, fix a bike, etc. Which is really all this is providing.
Things like paper maps are pretty cheap and require no power. I'm sure there are several pocket manuals you can pick up on amazon that document survival skills at a basic level as well.
ok, i understand your point. But i believe that we will have people trying to get knowledge about everything, in different places of the world, the few survivors would then, if they dont have guns and not willing to win by force, try to apply a subset of the book.
I think the key is actually to practice everything. I can't say for everyone, but as someone who is very bad at physical labour, I can't do a lot of the things that handymen consider to be trivial. They basically told me to watch YouTube videos, but those never worked out for me. I need someone to guide me, step by step, AND in the same direction (I get confused if he sits opposite to me because I need to map the actions to my side, which takes a lot of efforts -- this also happened to me when I learnt Karate), AND repeat many times.
Right now the only things I'm familiar with DIY is to pry open and destroy the floor of my basement because 1) flooded 3 times, and 2) I didn't need to preserve them anyway. The most advanced thing I ever did (with my father) was to change the battery for my car -- it took more than an hour because we happened to drop a wrench or whatever tool onto the bottom so it took us a lot of time to get it out. I bet for the handymen it's just 10 minutes.
This also gives me empathy for people who simply can't do simple things. My wife would never understand that. Fortunately, or unfortunately my son is like me in this aspect, so at least she will learn some empathy.
Agreed. We don't need a magic box that sits on the shelf and can ostensibly tell us how to make life-saving medication for ourselves when the day comes that society can no longer make it for us. We need hobbies that involve practicing the requisite skills so that when that day comes it is not only accessible in principle, but familiar in practice.
My theory is that a form of the Curse of the Gifted (child) applies to every young person now.
Children who excel at schooling for an extended amount of time tend to categorize the world into things that are easy (most challenges they face) and relatively impossible, as a behavioral optimization. Granted, this affects young people who are above average talent (maybe in a single vector), who are merely above-average or are temporarily developmentally above the curve. Sometimes they are humbled to learn that it's an ephemeral state, while still in grade school.
Amazing and capability extending things are easily learned through the use of technology today, which misleads children to fall into this same behavior at all levels.
Institutionalized fear of failure paired with laziness. At least, that's my best guess.
And yet, my son has had and overcome tons of challenges in his life. He's had language development problems, dyslexia, simply being able to do his work at school, and he has overcome them all. If anyone should know that anything he's bad at, he can still learn, it should be him.
It’s in the personality I think, or gene. My son has it too, which definitely comes from us. You just need to use a different way to encourage. Or maybe they just don’t want and you have to wait.
Agreed, and being willing to fail. I'm fairly handy, but I failed at a ton of small projects many times and/or built/repaired things to a less than ideal quality level before getting better at it. So half the battle is being willing to try and fail to continue to build skills and get better.
Your comment made me think that a carpenter simulator would be useful for learning different techniques and processes used by pros. Looks like such things exist. It wouldn't build muscle in the same way real work would. While less satisfying than finishing a real object I see great value in learning base skills in a no risk, no material cost, simulated environment.
I've seen a few "terminally online" friends try to saw a stick in half with a reciprocating saw and nearly take their fingers off.
Having 10 GB of PDFs about how to do stuff is probably like 0.1% of successful homesteading.
At the very minimum I think every person should be able to understand how to start a fire, filter some water, and maybe build a shelf or something (or a rudimentary shelter). No need to be super fancy.
I think this topic and related explorations are interesting as it pertains to rebuilding communities. We've become increasingly disconnected from what is needed for communities to function and thrive.
A related project is Open Source Ecology (terrible name), which aims to make the tools necessary to rebuild society accessible to everyone. Think houses and bulldozers, not hammers...impressive stuff.
there is a lot more to rebuilding communities besides technology.
the whole social aspect. caring for others. not being selfish. trust.
the problem is that lack/failure of those is the reason for society collapsing in the first place.
so rather than learning how to preserve my own food i am interested in learning how to build good will, collaboration and consensus, especially in a diverse society.
One phenomenon I’d not thought of until I encountered it, but that seems obvious in retrospect: in the immediate course of an exogenous shock (like natural disaster or war or large-scale social disruption), people tend to really come through for their neighbors [0].
The most reliable pattern seems to be a temporary burst of social cohesion. To the extent that durable negative social outcomes materialize, they tend to (1) roughly follow the contours of the same new material/social circumstances had they developed non-suddenly; and (2) take weeks and maybe months to overcome that initial swell of empathy.
In any case I agree that the human side is the important side—we owe a nod to communities like the Amish and religious orders who’ve done a lot of R&D into social cohesion technologies during blue skies!
Re [0]; that does not seem relevant for the scale and scope of something that would require not just surviving, but also rebuilding society. What makes you think an extremely limited event with a pervasive sense and experiential assumption, of it being a temporary state, would lead you to believe that would convey to a large scale, permanent state where services and resource availability and supply not just break down, but remain so?
You really should maybe look into the censored version of what actually happened during hurricane Katrina. It has been intentionally and deliberately suppressed. Knowing the truth could not only mean the difference between life and death for everyone you care about, but makes all of these “survival guides” utterly useless and even dangerous because their assumptions are based on not just inaccuracy, but lies.
Trade networks are far more important for rebuilding society than any of the above. Massive trade networks capable of moving goods thousands of miles.
The materials to run society don’t exist all in one place and except for the recyclable metals that are available in bulk in most urban environments and lumber mills which are relatively well distributed, people are going to start running out of basics really fast and society will never get off the ground.
The ones who have the best chance at survival are ironically the billion or so subsistence farmers in poverty who are largely excluded from the modern economy anyway.
Tight-knit religious groups will do really well in a catastrophic event. The trust is hard to duplicate outside of maybe the military or similar orgs. Even Mormons have prepping built into their lifestyle.
The vast majority of us in the first world would be completely
Incapable of the back breaking labor required to rebuild society. Days span 12 hours plus, all family members must participate and few can lean back and take the labor of others in the initial stages.
There is also a number of people who would chose to be violent to fight for the scraps of before rather than build what the future requires.
And if you think you’re up to it, you’re probably wildly over estimating yourself.
Open Source Ecology had such great promise, but Marcin got high on his own supply. It's effectively abandonware at this point. I can haz such disappoint.
I've been interested in this project for a long time. I'd like to go visit someday. I was wondering if you could say more about this.
I see a reddit discussion from a year ago mention (and I recall) the website/wiki being poorly laid out with actual CAD files difficult to find. Seems they could have used some help on that end.
Why not fork the project if the leadership failed? I see some links to an offshoot in Germany that might have gotten farther:
I was fascinated by it when it first came to light, but my understanding is that they seemed to suffer from ADHD, conflicting incentives, and founder's syndrome.
Food is on the front, but not clothing. Shows how little they know about society without modern technology. Women used to spend their days making thread - weaving and tailoring often was men's work, just making thread for clothing took all the time and effort of half of society. Food was also a lot of effort (and on the busy days women would be next to the men), but there is a lot more down time for men to do other needed work.
The primitive sexism above isn't required when you rebuild society, but you will often discover good reasons for that sexism.
Sounds just like Project NOMAD. Personally, I don't like the idea of using a power-hungry AI in a doomsday scenario when electricity would likely be in short supply. I have a simple Kiwix server setup instead, which will probably also be useless but it does make me feel a little better knowing I have it.
I think you are overestimating power usage by order of magnitude or two. For a much bigger Deepseek model, you can get <0.1J/token[1], or 36M output token for 1 kWH.
Or more than 500 book worth of token for 1 hot shower.
Why would electricity be in short supply? You have however much renewable electricity you have, and if that includes some solar your point is pretty much moot. Once the batteries, if you have any, are full you can watch videos or use AI or bake a cake or do whatever you want with the excess and any you don't use is 'wasted'.
If you need to "rebuild society" based on a collection of information you downloaded from the internet it's going to be a long, long time before you have replacements for those batteries. You'll want to treat them gently to make them last, they'll likely be the only ones you have for the rest of your life.
If your doomsday scenario with has so many solar panels and data centers that you can use AI, then it is not doomsday survival scenario. It is "something is a little broken" scenario.
Solar panels are everywhere. The only things that could stop them are a nuclear winter or targeted physical attacks. It's extremely unlikely that all the solar in a neighborhood will get destroyed.
When people talk about doomsday scenarios they usually don't mean a totally ruined world with absolutely nothing left. It's more like a war or pandemic that leaves half the population dead and society broke down.
Tech that's already built will stay there, and solar is not exactly high maintenance.
> It's more like a war or pandemic that leaves half the population dead and society broke down
Half the population dead is still a doomsday scenario especially for a technological civilization. We are far more dependent on others than we were the last time any society saw that scale of death. If you're thinking it would only take a decade or two to recover then I'd revise the estimate to maybe 10% of people killed. Those are heavy losses even for combat but not unrecoverable if that's the extent of the death toll. 50% dead would get ugly really quickly. A lot of critical information and skill would be lost and you'd be short half the workforce needed to operate things the way they're set up. Sure, there'd be less people and less demand for necessities but there'd probably be a lot more emergencies to deal with due to nothing working the way it should and everything being harder to accomplish.
Think how that would affect just fire departments as an example. Crew is only cut in half if you're lucky, maybe they're all gone if they are needed at home. More places are abandoned or unattended so fires that start get out of control. A lot of things are being done by people who are inexperienced or don't have the right skills or who are overloaded with additional work so more accidents are going to happen, electrical fires, car accidents, heavy machinery accidents, house fires caused by improvised cooking methods if there are blackouts, maybe even intentional arson.
That's only a fire department but everything would be affected. How do nuclear power plants fare with half the engineers and technicians to operate them? How do factories operate when half of the people who knew how to make new injection molds are dead? or the people who service the machines and equipment? what happens to medicine when half the surgeons die before they can pass on their skills? and so on for everything.
"Yes, we know a nuclear explosion will generate an electromagnetic pulse (EMP), which, depending on the circumstances, could disrupt certain electronic equipment, but the doom and gloom scenarios will not happen. That stuff belongs in Hollywood,” he says."
Maker's Guide to the Zombie Apocalypse
Defend Your Base with Simple Circuits,
Arduino, and Raspberry Pi
by Simon Monk
October 2015, 296 pp.
ISBN-13: 9781593276676
I'd like an Android version. Because I think I could occasionally power my Boox e-paper Android device, using solar power. I don't think I can power any of my PCs, without getting a generator, and if I'm on the move, I don't think I'm hauling a generator around.
A macbook has a battery capacity of under 100Wh and will fully charger from a 35W solar panel charger in under a day in the uk in summer, and in a couple of days in winter. Places further south like the US will charge faster than that.
- Order a solar panel that allows charging your phone + a usb stick that plugs into both your phone and a computer
- Get a small local LLM on your phone
- Download a bunch of pdfs of books useful for a lights out scenario, put them on your phone / ereader + your usb stick
I recommend information on: homesteading, electronics, methods to obtain food relevant to your location (fishing, farming), handiman stuff, basic health and medicine, local maps and food preservation.
Note that on the short term it's probably exposure, violence or disease from bad water/food that kills and it's best to stay home. On the long term what will kill most is caloric deficiency from inability to store enough food for the lean period (spring) where famine strikes hardest. You're better off cooperating than bunkering in because your odds of surviving harsh periods are much better that way. In most areas it's very difficult to survive entirely self sufficiently on food you grow/forage even if you've practiced for years and have everything already set up. And if you're not that ready, it's hopeless.
If your society has found itself in a situation where it needs to be rebuilt, it might be worth considering other forms of organisation, rather than a rebuild!
Jay Doscher has been building and evolving his Recovery Kit for a while. It's a portable RPi loaded with lots of useful content to load on it. Pretty neat build.
I feel like it should probably implement progressive disclosure. For example, you should first assume that electricity is wiped out, so you have some battery powered devices (phones/tablets/laptops). The first step should be to use whatever battery is left to inform people how to get distributed electricity generation up and running - to keep these devices running/charged. Then once electricity is up and running, figure out food and other production means. Then other aspects of society, order, care etc.
Is this only for Americans? It expects me to select a US state before I can do anything. It seems to be presented as more universal than it's meant to be.
The idea is interesting, like leaving a manual for civilization. Curious about how the author chooses which basic skills are worth putting in, after all, the space is limited, and what is not selected is very particular about.
i like to think if we launched Voyager 1 and Voyager 2 today we would probably put an AI Model on them with a snapshot of human knowledge and perhaps some kind of language layer to understand and establish a common language through interaction like in the movie Arrival & Project Hail Mary
Reading Dartnell's The Knowledge made me appreciate how fragile modern society is and how nearly impossible it would be to rebuild society after a major collapse, mostly due to our reliance on chemical industry, extremely complicated manufacturing processes with corresponding labor division and specialization, and large scale trading of valuable raw materials via shipping. Even just making transparent glass is an unbelievable achievement.
If you read up on what it will actually be like after an 'event', the real question is whether or not society picks back up. If it is a 'The Road' scenario no amount of preparing will do much for you. If it's a "Cultural Revolution" then having food kept by, if it is secret, will be extremely useful.
In between you have things like large scale nuclear war or meteor impact, where you need to survive the total collapse just long enough for civilization to get up and running again, maybe 6 months to a year at most (read On Thermonuclear War for an analysis). In the 'in between' scenarios, you need to worry about water and food and shelter, and if you survive more than 2 weeks post event you need to worry about all the people who are running out of food and water, because they will come knocking and at a minimum take all your food and water. Unless you are somewhere very remote and ideally around large extended family so you can protect each other this is a very tricky problem and I have never seen a reasonable solution for it, at least for anyone that doesn't live full time in a remote area.
Observation: any collapse scenario will mean
- none of us reading this will survive, statistically speaking
- survival is not necessarily a win, as it will be briefly and in the face on loss and trauma that cannot be integrated or "psychically survived."
Survival is that the society level or not at all.
A society surviving when there are destabilizing or hostile forces competing for valuable resources (of every kind, including your group farms and you and their other occupants), is possible, but generally only at scale and only at great cost.
We sink or swim together.
No reason to not learn valuable skills and add to the resilience of your local corner. But never make the mistake of daydreaming about being the protagonist in the collapse.
> Human knowledge is collective, distributed across the population. It has built on itself for centuries, becoming vast and increasingly specialized. Most of us are ignorant about the fundamental principles of the civilization that supports us, happily utilizing the latest—or even the most basic—technology without having the slightest idea of why it works or how it came to be. If you had to go back to absolute basics, like some sort of postcataclysmic Robinson Crusoe, would you know how to re-create an internal combustion engine, put together a microscope, get metals out of rock, accurately tell time, weave fibers into clothing, or even how to produce food for yourself?
> Regarded as one of the brightest young scientists of his generation, Lewis Dartnell proposes that the key to preserving civilization in an apocalyptic scenario is to provide a quickstart guide, adapted to cataclysmic circumstances. The Knowledge describes many of the modern technologies we employ, but first it explains the fundamentals upon which they are built. Every piece of technology rests on an enormous support network of other technologies, all interlinked and mutually dependent. You can’t hope to build a radio, for example, without understanding how to acquire the raw materials it requires, as well as generate the electricity needed to run it. But Dartnell doesn’t just provide specific information for starting over; he also reveals the greatest invention of them all—the phenomenal knowledge-generating machine that is the scientific method itself. This would allow survivors to learn technological advances not explicitly explored in The Knowledge as well as things we have yet to discover.
I think this is a solid idea that a lot of people are pursuing right now
Project Nomad, Nomad MK4, Zimi, and others are popping up like this, trying to create offline caches of information
Definitely a noble goal, but I'd love to combine their efforts into the most efficient options.
All of the above are using .zim files for access to large amounts of compressed information; any resources donated to KIWIX will likely benefit all of these projects immensely.
A lot of our modern technical civilization was facilitated by easy to reach mineral resources including fossil hydrocarbons, that are not only useful as fuel but as the basic input for a fucking huge amount of chemical things.
Then, we have all other minerals like copper, but those at least will be easily "mined" from our ruins. But without cheap fossil fuels, things will get way more complicated.
I noted this in another comment, but we can theoretically rebuild society even without hard-to-manufacture resources like fossil fuels. Up until about the 19th century, almost every civilization has been working with wood, stone, some metal, animal labor and animal products. These societies have also endured for hundreds of years, with their main threats being cultural collapse like in Rome, military invasion from larger civilizations like Rome or Babylon, crop failures (due to either natural drought or destructive farming practices) like in the Indus Valley, or disease like the Black Death. Day-to-day life and society was perfectly possible without modern materials.
Nah. I did tons of research for this for a book I'm working on where someone gets isekai'd to a world without fossil fuels (the planet itself is too new for that). Right now, our world is built around fossil fuels. Oil, specifically. If it was built around solar and hydro power, our standard of living would be about the same.
A lot of things would be different, of course, but we'd still have homes with more electricity than we can use and cars that can take us across the country. The "hard part" would be transporting heavy goods (big rigs) over land and mining (in general).
The big thing that would be missing in such a world is people living in the middle of nowhere at the same standards as people who live in cities. Without fossil fuels, it makes no sense to build a neighborhood that's 200 miles away from the city just for retirees. Just transporting the building materials out there would be cost prohibitive.
It's possible that they could build using local timber and whatnot but think about how much it would cost to say, get a septic system pumped out. The cost of diesel for the truck (which would have to be biodiesel, probably made from algae) would make the operation a great big expense compared to using city sewers. Just delivering mail would be vastly more expensive.
We could still have suburbs but they'd have shared infrastructure such as biogas digesters with everyone being very careful with what they dump into the system. They'd use that biogas to heat their homes in the winter and it would probably be used by local industry (e.g. forges) as well (in addition to heliostat arrays that reflect the sun's heat right into the forge).
Water-based shipping and travel would be much more prevalent than they are in our world. Pretty much every community/city would need to settle near a major waterway in order to get reduced prices on (shipped) goods. Also, anywhere with volcanic activity nearby (for geothermal power and sulfur supply) would be prime real estate!
"Stored properly" is doing a lot of work here. When you buy freeze dried meals you can have a high confidence they are stored properly. When you do it yourself there is a very good chance that you mess it up. You can't just buy a FoodSaver and voila.
The LDS church emphasizes having emergency supplies, and they maintain a surprisingly good guide. Cool, low moisture, pest resistant, air tight storage should be good for well over 25 years.
I like the dry-ice method, where you throw some bags in a barrel, add dry ice, wait for it to sublimate and displace all oxygen, and then seal it up. That should last 50+ years in theory.
Sometimes, I almost wish for the apocalypse so that all these ridiculous "everything you need to know" projects are put to the test.
There are three things that matter in most real-world emergencies: financial and social safety net, bare necessities (toilet paper + bucket, water, food, etc), and practical skills.
Your plan can't be a copy of Wikipedia you're "going to read" when a disaster strikes, and it can't be a cache of seeds you're "going to grow" into crops with zero farming experience, in the middle of winter, with no suitable land. And in general, it shouldn't be anything complex, because complexity reduces flexibility and adds failure points.
Spending money on cool high-tech gadgets - a category that I guess now includes "doomsday" LLMs - isn't emergency preparedness.
For a solution for "rebuilding society," it is conspicuously light on the "society" part. Nothing on de-escalation, managing groups in survival situations, or anything like that.
Also... if I was in a long-term doomsday situation like that, I would be extremely adverse to relying on any complex electronics. A print library is what you'd want there.
Couldn't agree more. Before we even talk about how to rebuild society, we should spend far more time talking about how to prevent societal collapse in the first place.
This should be so much more important and universally embraced, but it doesn't let you buy cool gadgets and LARP as a movie character.
However, assuming society already has collapsed, you're going to have a much bigger problem organizing (and defending against other organizations of) your neighbors, than you will trying to build a rain barrel.
"Betty the bombs just dropped. We need to get to the shelter. Thank god I read that chapter on how to de-escalate and manage the group 7 years ago, now we won't die. Despite living a life in a fully integrated world civilization and having never tried out any of our survival equipment or food, our 3 months of rice is going to make the difference because I know how to de-escalate whenever the starving people with guns pull up."
I agree though, a print library is probably more valuable to whatever survivors eventually turn up to look through your stuff.
The de-escalation is for when you come back out of the shelter and there are other survivors you have to interact with. If starving people with guns pull up, you could potentially convince them to let you join. Bigger groups are stronger.
Despite what the Walking Dead would have you believe, it won't be total anarchy and looting. Neighbors will work together and support each other against outsiders. Groups will coalesce and co-operate. Humans are social, tribal creatures. We automatically form societies and tribes, especially during a calamity.
> If starving people with guns pull up, you could potentially convince them to let you join.
You think that if you read a book about de-escalation you will talk your way out of giving up all your stuff to starving survivors in a post apocalypse?
> Neighbors will work together and support each other against outsiders.
Do all your neighbors have enough food to survive? Are you going to have enough to feed all of them? After 5 days with no food your neighbors will take whatever you have, and kill you if that is what they have to do to get your food. They might cry afterward, but they will do it.
> Humans are social, tribal creatures. We automatically form societies and tribes, especially during a calamity.
Your argument is you will be safe because humans are tribal. That argument works all the time, so why aren't people safe all the time? People around the world are safe more or less exactly in proportion to how well fed their neighbors are. If your neighbors are starving you are not safe, no matter how nice they are when they have a full stomach.
Their argument is actually that tribal skills are really important.
For instance, convincing your neighbors to be ready for problems before the problems. That builds your social capital as well as prevents them from starving before you do.
> You think that if you read a book about de-escalation
Well I'd be better off than if I didn't read the book. Learning social skills and negotiation in real life is way more important obviously.
> Do all your neighbors have enough food to survive?
My neighbors would have food because I would share and so would they. And then we'd work out something to find or grow more food. Maybe, if it's really dire, we'd form our own looting band. Either way fighting each other would be disastrous for all of us long-term. Maybe survive together or definitely die alone.
> After 5 days with no food your neighbors will kill you for whatever you have.
Is that what you'd do if you were that neighbor? If yes, I'm sorry to tell you that you aren't normal.
If they kill me, who's going to stand with them when unfriendly people from outside the neighborhood show up?
> Your argument is you will be safe because humans are tribal. That argument works all the time, so why aren't people safe all the time?
People mostly are safe. You can walk down the street with virtually zero fear of getting stabbed. Or I don't know, maybe you're just a naturally fearful person. I'm not.
So this is supposed to prepare for a scenario where civilization completely ends but you still have access to electricity and modern computer hardware, including hardware capable of running local AI models? Seems absurd. Why do so many tech people fantasize about ways to fix fantastical apocalyptic scenarios instead of trying to address real crises that are happening now?
As valuable as stuff like Wikipedia or this project is, the infrastructural barrier to entry is rather high for future generations. One of the reasons Renaissance scholars were able to rediscover and recover ancient writing is because paper is immediately accessible with just the paper and your eyeballs, while the information on it uses encoding specifications that are extremely universal by virtue of most of educated society being intimately familiar with the workings. Compare that to hard drives or Blu-rays, where you need highly advanced and highly specific equipment to read, on top of knowing exactly what encoding is used (knowledge that few people even in tech circles makes a deep study of).
Digital storage is good for information density, but not longevity or historical record.
This project could have been in the "[subject].pdf" category, maybe with a nice html page that contains a search index, but instead this is more like "[subject] analysis software" which is unlikely to run on any piece of scrap hardware that will still work after society has collapsed.
this has to be the dumbest thing I've seen today. how are you supposed to "survive" with something that is a program that needs to run on your computer which runs on electricity? and "survive" what exactly? because if there's an electricity outage you're not gonna survive nothing. what an idiotic idea.
I've seen people mentioning batteries and solar panels. are you really gonna waste that precious energy running a energy hungry laptop to read your manual that you probably couldn't follow if you tried? you'd be dead in two or three business days max.
So this book assumes electronic devices will continue to function if society collapses? Laptop and phone batteries die, a collapsed society wont have a working electronic infrastructure for a whole while.
If you have ever seen phone charging stalls in rural Africa, you can easily imagine that, in a doomsday scenario, the dude who has the solar panel and the functioning computer becomes some sort of local shaman and indispensable. :D
I, too, enjoy power fantasies where my particular skills and obsessions make me indispensable.
Once the AI Singularity arrives, it's natural to assume that the Machine Gods will venerate their ancestors, mechanical typewriters. As a collector and restorer of old typerwriters, I will of course be revered as a High Priest of the Ink Ribbon.
I wish people would be this passionate about improving society instead. Don't be delusional. If society collapses, you'll probably just get an infection few months in and die.
These kinds of topics remind me of libertarians going off grid, not realizing that the idea of property only works because governments and social support structures exist.
Do we really want to let society crumble? I do not argue that Western society is deeply sick, but an abrupt collapse of the current order will leave us in an intermediary period of poverty and war (see the French and Russian revolutions). Even the American revolution notably kept in place a lot of the pre-existing English culture and legal customs that the colonies were already following before England started interfering.
One thing to ponder is how advanced we want the next society to be. Up until around the 19th century, societies got by with primarily wood, stone, some metals, and various animals and animal-derived substances. While we were not getting to the moon with these, we were still able to sustain stable civilizations with these resources for millennia. Furthermore, these resources are still quite available and quite accessible, assuming we do not nuke the entire biosphere in one go.
Of course, the lack of modern materials would put a damper on building massive populations and our fight against microscopic threats (see: the Black Death), but society is still quite possible, if less expansive.
They don't seem to list the information anywhere, either.
No mobile version is an oversight. It's easier to power a phone in an emergency than it is to power a laptop or desktop.
What a decidedly odd set of choices.
- Since this is python, it could be served via a Raspberry Pi or similar low power device, then you connect via mobile over wifi. This allows multiple people to use it at once.
- There is an iPad build on github. Presumably the authors don't want to pay the fee to build official iPad apps (which is surprisingly expensive).
I'm not sure about the PDFs, it seems logical/easy to do, but it might end up being too large to store, and might be something you'd generate manually for certain topics.
If it's important to share, every modern phone can act as a hotspot / server. That would be a lot easier than something which has to run from a dedicated computer.
This looks like one of those projects where the intention is good, but no one has sat down and talked to potential users or disaster recovery experts.
Also, iPhones can sort of serve HTTP, so long as the app doing the serving is in the foreground the entire time. My experience is Apple does not have serving HTTP as an approved method for running in background mode, that's limited to stuff like audio playback and such. This is probably why the mobile version of Lastbook doesn't support networking, and is just a native Swift application.
The monetary cost is only the beginning. The approval process is onerous and slow, and getting worse with the onslaught of AI slop clogging up the queue.
But, also, locked-down devices, like iOS or now Android, are not what I want to rely on if the shit hits the fan.
Booking is assuming the end of civilization, probably chaos, migration.. i can imagine, that if you can power one device, would make much more sense a small e-ink tablet, not python served via raspi AND a device to read it..
But the ultimate in resiliency is to learn all this stuff now. I can already do first aid, can/preserve food, have water purification on hand, wire up a solar setup, make basic repairs to anything in my home, fix a bike, etc. Which is really all this is providing.
Things like paper maps are pretty cheap and require no power. I'm sure there are several pocket manuals you can pick up on amazon that document survival skills at a basic level as well.
Right now the only things I'm familiar with DIY is to pry open and destroy the floor of my basement because 1) flooded 3 times, and 2) I didn't need to preserve them anyway. The most advanced thing I ever did (with my father) was to change the battery for my car -- it took more than an hour because we happened to drop a wrench or whatever tool onto the bottom so it took us a lot of time to get it out. I bet for the handymen it's just 10 minutes.
This also gives me empathy for people who simply can't do simple things. My wife would never understand that. Fortunately, or unfortunately my son is like me in this aspect, so at least she will learn some empathy.
The more you practice the better you get. If you did home improvement you would get better at it.
If you wouldnt expect to be able to code at one try Im not sure why you would expect to be good at home improvement in one try.
Children who excel at schooling for an extended amount of time tend to categorize the world into things that are easy (most challenges they face) and relatively impossible, as a behavioral optimization. Granted, this affects young people who are above average talent (maybe in a single vector), who are merely above-average or are temporarily developmentally above the curve. Sometimes they are humbled to learn that it's an ephemeral state, while still in grade school.
Amazing and capability extending things are easily learned through the use of technology today, which misleads children to fall into this same behavior at all levels.
Institutionalized fear of failure paired with laziness. At least, that's my best guess.
People learn from your example, not from your advice. Particularly for children.
I've seen a few "terminally online" friends try to saw a stick in half with a reciprocating saw and nearly take their fingers off.
Having 10 GB of PDFs about how to do stuff is probably like 0.1% of successful homesteading.
At the very minimum I think every person should be able to understand how to start a fire, filter some water, and maybe build a shelf or something (or a rudimentary shelter). No need to be super fancy.
A related project is Open Source Ecology (terrible name), which aims to make the tools necessary to rebuild society accessible to everyone. Think houses and bulldozers, not hammers...impressive stuff.
https://www.opensourceecology.org
the whole social aspect. caring for others. not being selfish. trust.
the problem is that lack/failure of those is the reason for society collapsing in the first place.
so rather than learning how to preserve my own food i am interested in learning how to build good will, collaboration and consensus, especially in a diverse society.
The most reliable pattern seems to be a temporary burst of social cohesion. To the extent that durable negative social outcomes materialize, they tend to (1) roughly follow the contours of the same new material/social circumstances had they developed non-suddenly; and (2) take weeks and maybe months to overcome that initial swell of empathy.
In any case I agree that the human side is the important side—we owe a nod to communities like the Amish and religious orders who’ve done a lot of R&D into social cohesion technologies during blue skies!
[0] (e.g. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7115229/ and https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/028072709801600305 and many others in the genre)
You really should maybe look into the censored version of what actually happened during hurricane Katrina. It has been intentionally and deliberately suppressed. Knowing the truth could not only mean the difference between life and death for everyone you care about, but makes all of these “survival guides” utterly useless and even dangerous because their assumptions are based on not just inaccuracy, but lies.
The materials to run society don’t exist all in one place and except for the recyclable metals that are available in bulk in most urban environments and lumber mills which are relatively well distributed, people are going to start running out of basics really fast and society will never get off the ground.
The ones who have the best chance at survival are ironically the billion or so subsistence farmers in poverty who are largely excluded from the modern economy anyway.
There is also a number of people who would chose to be violent to fight for the scraps of before rather than build what the future requires.
And if you think you’re up to it, you’re probably wildly over estimating yourself.
I see a reddit discussion from a year ago mention (and I recall) the website/wiki being poorly laid out with actual CAD files difficult to find. Seems they could have used some help on that end.
Why not fork the project if the leadership failed? I see some links to an offshoot in Germany that might have gotten farther:
https://www.ose-germany.de/die-bewegung/
I had an AI synthesize a doc on the issues: https://share.google/aimode/uT3tYdwHz1tMwQypt
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pocket_Ref
* https://sequoiapublishing.com/product/pocket-ref/
* https://archive.org/details/pocketref0000glov/page/n1/mode/2...
The primitive sexism above isn't required when you rebuild society, but you will often discover good reasons for that sexism.
Or more than 500 book worth of token for 1 hot shower.
[1]: https://inferencex.semianalysis.com/infx/inference/deepseek-...
When people talk about doomsday scenarios they usually don't mean a totally ruined world with absolutely nothing left. It's more like a war or pandemic that leaves half the population dead and society broke down.
Tech that's already built will stay there, and solar is not exactly high maintenance.
Half the population dead is still a doomsday scenario especially for a technological civilization. We are far more dependent on others than we were the last time any society saw that scale of death. If you're thinking it would only take a decade or two to recover then I'd revise the estimate to maybe 10% of people killed. Those are heavy losses even for combat but not unrecoverable if that's the extent of the death toll. 50% dead would get ugly really quickly. A lot of critical information and skill would be lost and you'd be short half the workforce needed to operate things the way they're set up. Sure, there'd be less people and less demand for necessities but there'd probably be a lot more emergencies to deal with due to nothing working the way it should and everything being harder to accomplish.
Think how that would affect just fire departments as an example. Crew is only cut in half if you're lucky, maybe they're all gone if they are needed at home. More places are abandoned or unattended so fires that start get out of control. A lot of things are being done by people who are inexperienced or don't have the right skills or who are overloaded with additional work so more accidents are going to happen, electrical fires, car accidents, heavy machinery accidents, house fires caused by improvised cooking methods if there are blackouts, maybe even intentional arson.
That's only a fire department but everything would be affected. How do nuclear power plants fare with half the engineers and technicians to operate them? How do factories operate when half of the people who knew how to make new injection molds are dead? or the people who service the machines and equipment? what happens to medicine when half the surgeons die before they can pass on their skills? and so on for everything.
If you have extra power from your not-destroyed solar panels, it's better to use that power so your neighbor has refridgeration, than to run an LLM.
https://www.lanl.gov/media/publications/national-security-sc...
Maximize optionality. Portfolio theory.
You don’t know how hungry the systems will be sometime in the future and you also don’t know what energy sources you will have access to.
https://github.com/Immortal-Protocols/lastbook/issues/37
And really, why not Kiwix?
- Order a solar panel that allows charging your phone + a usb stick that plugs into both your phone and a computer
- Get a small local LLM on your phone
- Download a bunch of pdfs of books useful for a lights out scenario, put them on your phone / ereader + your usb stick
I recommend information on: homesteading, electronics, methods to obtain food relevant to your location (fishing, farming), handiman stuff, basic health and medicine, local maps and food preservation.
Note that on the short term it's probably exposure, violence or disease from bad water/food that kills and it's best to stay home. On the long term what will kill most is caloric deficiency from inability to store enough food for the lean period (spring) where famine strikes hardest. You're better off cooperating than bunkering in because your odds of surviving harsh periods are much better that way. In most areas it's very difficult to survive entirely self sufficiently on food you grow/forage even if you've practiced for years and have everything already set up. And if you're not that ready, it's hopeless.
First shared here in 2019...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21647398
Older laptop: 16yo and dead, currently kept as display because stickers are pretty.
Netbook: 10yo and still alive, but only 20G of storage.
Slightly less older laptop: 10yo and works, but I had to take the battery out when it started visibly expanding.
Current laptop: 5yo and works, but battery life just cut down by 40% overnight.
So that's 1 out of 4 devices that could work, 2 if you think you can run an LLM from an SD Card on a 10yo device. Those are not great odds.
[0]: https://www.howtoinventeverything.com/
In between you have things like large scale nuclear war or meteor impact, where you need to survive the total collapse just long enough for civilization to get up and running again, maybe 6 months to a year at most (read On Thermonuclear War for an analysis). In the 'in between' scenarios, you need to worry about water and food and shelter, and if you survive more than 2 weeks post event you need to worry about all the people who are running out of food and water, because they will come knocking and at a minimum take all your food and water. Unless you are somewhere very remote and ideally around large extended family so you can protect each other this is a very tricky problem and I have never seen a reasonable solution for it, at least for anyone that doesn't live full time in a remote area.
Survival is that the society level or not at all.
A society surviving when there are destabilizing or hostile forces competing for valuable resources (of every kind, including your group farms and you and their other occupants), is possible, but generally only at scale and only at great cost.
We sink or swim together.
No reason to not learn valuable skills and add to the resilience of your local corner. But never make the mistake of daydreaming about being the protagonist in the collapse.
> Human knowledge is collective, distributed across the population. It has built on itself for centuries, becoming vast and increasingly specialized. Most of us are ignorant about the fundamental principles of the civilization that supports us, happily utilizing the latest—or even the most basic—technology without having the slightest idea of why it works or how it came to be. If you had to go back to absolute basics, like some sort of postcataclysmic Robinson Crusoe, would you know how to re-create an internal combustion engine, put together a microscope, get metals out of rock, accurately tell time, weave fibers into clothing, or even how to produce food for yourself?
> Regarded as one of the brightest young scientists of his generation, Lewis Dartnell proposes that the key to preserving civilization in an apocalyptic scenario is to provide a quickstart guide, adapted to cataclysmic circumstances. The Knowledge describes many of the modern technologies we employ, but first it explains the fundamentals upon which they are built. Every piece of technology rests on an enormous support network of other technologies, all interlinked and mutually dependent. You can’t hope to build a radio, for example, without understanding how to acquire the raw materials it requires, as well as generate the electricity needed to run it. But Dartnell doesn’t just provide specific information for starting over; he also reveals the greatest invention of them all—the phenomenal knowledge-generating machine that is the scientific method itself. This would allow survivors to learn technological advances not explicitly explored in The Knowledge as well as things we have yet to discover.
* https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/18114087-the-knowledg...
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Knowledge:_How_to_Rebuild_...
* https://the-knowledge.org/
Project Nomad, Nomad MK4, Zimi, and others are popping up like this, trying to create offline caches of information
Definitely a noble goal, but I'd love to combine their efforts into the most efficient options.
All of the above are using .zim files for access to large amounts of compressed information; any resources donated to KIWIX will likely benefit all of these projects immensely.
Then, we have all other minerals like copper, but those at least will be easily "mined" from our ruins. But without cheap fossil fuels, things will get way more complicated.
A lot of things would be different, of course, but we'd still have homes with more electricity than we can use and cars that can take us across the country. The "hard part" would be transporting heavy goods (big rigs) over land and mining (in general).
The big thing that would be missing in such a world is people living in the middle of nowhere at the same standards as people who live in cities. Without fossil fuels, it makes no sense to build a neighborhood that's 200 miles away from the city just for retirees. Just transporting the building materials out there would be cost prohibitive.
It's possible that they could build using local timber and whatnot but think about how much it would cost to say, get a septic system pumped out. The cost of diesel for the truck (which would have to be biodiesel, probably made from algae) would make the operation a great big expense compared to using city sewers. Just delivering mail would be vastly more expensive.
We could still have suburbs but they'd have shared infrastructure such as biogas digesters with everyone being very careful with what they dump into the system. They'd use that biogas to heat their homes in the winter and it would probably be used by local industry (e.g. forges) as well (in addition to heliostat arrays that reflect the sun's heat right into the forge).
Water-based shipping and travel would be much more prevalent than they are in our world. Pretty much every community/city would need to settle near a major waterway in order to get reduced prices on (shipped) goods. Also, anywhere with volcanic activity nearby (for geothermal power and sulfur supply) would be prime real estate!
- $105 - 28 servings of Mountian House meals - 8,000 calories
- $105 - 150 servings of ReadyWise meals - 25,280 calories
- $18 - 25lbs of white rice - 40,000 calories
- $24 - 25lbs dry beans - 20,000 calories
- $18 - 7lbs dry pasta - 11,340 calories
Stored properly, the latter three are stable for 25+ years.
- $12.99 - 6qts vegetable oil - 49,920 calories
Gonna be eatin good in the apocalypse!
I like the dry-ice method, where you throw some bags in a barrel, add dry ice, wait for it to sublimate and displace all oxygen, and then seal it up. That should last 50+ years in theory.
https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/manual/emergency-p...
There are three things that matter in most real-world emergencies: financial and social safety net, bare necessities (toilet paper + bucket, water, food, etc), and practical skills.
Your plan can't be a copy of Wikipedia you're "going to read" when a disaster strikes, and it can't be a cache of seeds you're "going to grow" into crops with zero farming experience, in the middle of winter, with no suitable land. And in general, it shouldn't be anything complex, because complexity reduces flexibility and adds failure points.
Spending money on cool high-tech gadgets - a category that I guess now includes "doomsday" LLMs - isn't emergency preparedness.
Also... if I was in a long-term doomsday situation like that, I would be extremely adverse to relying on any complex electronics. A print library is what you'd want there.
This should be so much more important and universally embraced, but it doesn't let you buy cool gadgets and LARP as a movie character.
However, assuming society already has collapsed, you're going to have a much bigger problem organizing (and defending against other organizations of) your neighbors, than you will trying to build a rain barrel.
"Betty the bombs just dropped. We need to get to the shelter. Thank god I read that chapter on how to de-escalate and manage the group 7 years ago, now we won't die. Despite living a life in a fully integrated world civilization and having never tried out any of our survival equipment or food, our 3 months of rice is going to make the difference because I know how to de-escalate whenever the starving people with guns pull up."
I agree though, a print library is probably more valuable to whatever survivors eventually turn up to look through your stuff.
Despite what the Walking Dead would have you believe, it won't be total anarchy and looting. Neighbors will work together and support each other against outsiders. Groups will coalesce and co-operate. Humans are social, tribal creatures. We automatically form societies and tribes, especially during a calamity.
You think that if you read a book about de-escalation you will talk your way out of giving up all your stuff to starving survivors in a post apocalypse?
> Neighbors will work together and support each other against outsiders.
Do all your neighbors have enough food to survive? Are you going to have enough to feed all of them? After 5 days with no food your neighbors will take whatever you have, and kill you if that is what they have to do to get your food. They might cry afterward, but they will do it.
> Humans are social, tribal creatures. We automatically form societies and tribes, especially during a calamity.
Your argument is you will be safe because humans are tribal. That argument works all the time, so why aren't people safe all the time? People around the world are safe more or less exactly in proportion to how well fed their neighbors are. If your neighbors are starving you are not safe, no matter how nice they are when they have a full stomach.
For instance, convincing your neighbors to be ready for problems before the problems. That builds your social capital as well as prevents them from starving before you do.
Well I'd be better off than if I didn't read the book. Learning social skills and negotiation in real life is way more important obviously.
> Do all your neighbors have enough food to survive?
My neighbors would have food because I would share and so would they. And then we'd work out something to find or grow more food. Maybe, if it's really dire, we'd form our own looting band. Either way fighting each other would be disastrous for all of us long-term. Maybe survive together or definitely die alone.
> After 5 days with no food your neighbors will kill you for whatever you have.
Is that what you'd do if you were that neighbor? If yes, I'm sorry to tell you that you aren't normal.
If they kill me, who's going to stand with them when unfriendly people from outside the neighborhood show up?
> Your argument is you will be safe because humans are tribal. That argument works all the time, so why aren't people safe all the time?
People mostly are safe. You can walk down the street with virtually zero fear of getting stabbed. Or I don't know, maybe you're just a naturally fearful person. I'm not.
Digital storage is good for information density, but not longevity or historical record.
This could be a shell script or a URL to a website.
Society is doomed.
This project could have been in the "[subject].pdf" category, maybe with a nice html page that contains a search index, but instead this is more like "[subject] analysis software" which is unlikely to run on any piece of scrap hardware that will still work after society has collapsed.
The world _and_ the US. We're being spoiled!
This is a fun read:
https://github.com/Immortal-Protocols/lastbook/blob/main/con...
I've seen people mentioning batteries and solar panels. are you really gonna waste that precious energy running a energy hungry laptop to read your manual that you probably couldn't follow if you tried? you'd be dead in two or three business days max.
unbelievable.
Once the AI Singularity arrives, it's natural to assume that the Machine Gods will venerate their ancestors, mechanical typewriters. As a collector and restorer of old typerwriters, I will of course be revered as a High Priest of the Ink Ribbon.
These kinds of topics remind me of libertarians going off grid, not realizing that the idea of property only works because governments and social support structures exist.
On the other hand we have already extracted things like metals and they are much easier to get at.
Of course, the lack of modern materials would put a damper on building massive populations and our fight against microscopic threats (see: the Black Death), but society is still quite possible, if less expansive.